LUCID Hypoallergenic Waterproof Mattress Protector Reviews Summary

Waterproof Quality

Pros:

• "Despite being waterproof, these pillow protectors are actually soft on the outside."
• "Not one drop came through!"
• "It works better than any mattress cover I've ever tried - stays in place for weeks at a time through normal sleeping and sheet changes, then holds up without leaks when the cat goes through a crisis."
• "It truly is waterproof, as my dog threw up in my bed AGAIN and the mattress was untouched."
• "So, my cat peed on my bed the other day. I found out by sitting in it. Let’s just say that I was less than thrilled. HOWEVER, I had this mattress cover on my bed, and NOTHING went through to the mattress beneath!"
• "This has completely protected my foam mattress from 3 times a cat I was sitting has peed on my bed."
• "I can honestly say this is TRULY waterproof! the day I put it on my bed, he once again had an accident BUT the mattress protector did not leak!"

Cons:

• "We purchased this mattress cover for a spare bed. We have an older cat that occasionally has accidents, so we wanted to protect the mattress. This cover worked for ~10 washes and was no longer waterproof."
• "However, I was surprised to find it has very wide non-waterproof borders - I measured 14 inches on each side, 16 at the ends."
• "It was great while it lasted, but my toddler peed on his bed and it went straight through, less than a year after purchase."
• "I discovered that my cat had an accident minutes after it happened and it had already soaked through to the mattress."
• "While this product is soft, it is not waterproof."
• "I purchased this towards the end of 2020. Not even 2 years into owning it, it fails."
• "Absolutely does NOT protect."

Comfort and Feel

Pros:

• "Honestly, wonderful quality."
• "I couldn't feel a hint of dampness or moisture."
• "It doesn't make any noise when you move around, and I was very glad to find out that it didn't make me hotter at night."
• "It also doesn’t have that annoying plastic crinkling sound like most other mattress protectors do, which is SUCH an A+ in my book."
• "It is comfy on the bed and you don’t know there is a pad on the mattress."
• "These cases are so soft and smooth and cool to my face that i just can't wait for my head to hit the pillow."
• "This protector is covered with cotton material like a sheet. Awesome."

Cons:

• "The darn thing feels like a cheap beach towel, not at all soft or anything comfortable to sleep on."
• "Disappointed with this mattress protector. We bought it to put on our new Leesa matress and it is very noisy and makes our bed feel crunchy/uncomfortable."
• "The plastic side is more plasticky than the one I had previously, and is slightly noisy."
• "One thing I don't love about this cover is the way it sounds/makes the sheets feel."
• "The swishy, almost plasticy sound bothers us slightly, and it makes the sheets feel like they aren't as soft due to the terry underneath."
• "I dislike it due to the noise and the feel of it."
• "It's difficult to keep tight on the mattress because it's usable on a thicker mattress."

Durability and Maintenance

Pros:

• "Washes spectacularly in the washer machine."
• "We’ve had it for about 1.5-2 years and it’s still going strong!"
• "Best waterproof mattress cover ever! I've bought 4 now for different beds."
• "Even after months of use, multiple washings, and cats climbing all over it... it never bothers me when I'm moving around in bed."
• "I have bought these for every mattress in our house (our own, kids, guest room). They are still waterproof even after many times going through the laundry."
• "Both times the urine has not gotten into the mattress, and a rigorous wash and dry posed no issue."
• "Have washed it multiple times with no problems."

Cons:

• "I will say that I did not dry this after washing though as other reviews said it fell apart."
• "This started leaking after maybe 3.5 years of use a several washes."
• "So it lasted 4 + years the water resistant backing has started to come off in small flake pieces it looks as if if has dried out and is cracking."
• "The old protector tore to shreds in the dryer even though it said it could be dried."
• "The top surface shrank just a bit after a few washes, so it doesn't as completely cover the top of the mattress edges anymore."
• "Second one started falling apart around the elastic fitting area immediately."
• "It leaked, sadly... it soaked right through this pad."