Xtreme Comforts Pillows Sleeping GreenGuard Reviews Summary

Comfort and Support

Pros:

• "No matter where or how I shift positions during the night, I never really have to mess with my pillow to get ty support I need, and I don’t feel like I’m adjusting my sleep habits for the pillow to be comfortable but supportive."
• "The pillow feels cool to sleep on and has a perfect balance of softness and support."
• "This is the most comfortable pillow ever. And so supportive."
• "It kept my head cool all night without me having to flip it like I've had to do with other previous pillows and it gave me the support that I need."
• "I absolutely love my pillow. I have a cervical spine injury and no pillow worked for me until I ordered this in King."
• "This pillow is great because I can adjust the thickness by removing the proper amount of stuffing."
• "This is by far the best pillow I've owned! It's soft but sturdy, the outside liner washed well. Absolutely the support I need without being too bulky or too flat."

Cons:

• "After having the pillow for more than a few weeks, it is now to the point where every night I have to rotate the pillow more than once to avoid it flattening around my neck area."
• "The memory foam filler shifts and wherever my head rests, the filler squishes down and ends up flat without supporting my neck or head."
• "The foam does not support the head and neck area as well after it is used for a few weeks."
• "No matter what I do to adjust the fill, or how many times I fluff the pillow in the dryer before going to bed, I wake up feeling like I slept on a rock."
• "I found that while sleeping on my side, my head sunk below my shoulder and strained my neck."
• "I have great support when I first lie down but after a few hours my head has sunk into the pillow and the spot under my head has become a hard mass."
• "It compresses too much and it’s very hot."

Adjustability

Pros:

• "The fact that you can adjust the size of this pillow is a game changer."
• "Has COMPLETELY adjustable comfort and firmness--just add or subtract the foam inside."
• "It’s not lumpy like other 'chunks of memory foam' pillows because the pieces of foam are super small."
• "I like the adjustability of it."
• "You can adjust the level of foam inside it for your comfort."
• "Easy to customize pillow by removing stuffing."
• "What's nice about these pillows is you can add or remove foam."

Cons:

• "Neither of them have zippers on them to access the stuffing on the inside."
• "The pillow is COMPLETELY sewn shut, not getting inside to unzip and remove the foam."
• "It’s advertised that there’s a zipper, but there’s not one."
• "The removal of extra stuffing is confusing. Where do I put it?"
• "The seller should know this!! I bought this pillow mainly because it said I could customize it and remove some shredded foam to my liking."
• "It's described as an adjustable pillow, infact NYT Wirecutter also ranks it high because of the ability to adjust the height to ones need but there is no zipper in both the pillows I ordered."
• "The pillows feel fine, but they look nothing like the pictures and the full isn't adjustable."

Material Quality

Pros:

• "Received and tossed in dryer as advised. Puffed up nice."
• "The outside and inner covers are very well made with smooth fabric and excellent stitching."
• "Both pillow cases are a blend of 40% bamboo and 60% polyester. Both cases are equally as soft and lovely."
• "This pillow is has a nice soft cover and comes overstuffed with a zippered end to remove stuffing to your liking."
• "The pillow material quality is good."
• "This pillow is cuddly soft and fluffy."
• "This pillow is heavy and firm, but also soft and comfortable."

Cons:

• "The pillow is much worse than regular foam pillows. Just as hard and uncomfortable, only lumpy and messy."
• "The shredded foam fill makes unpleasant, firm clumps."
• "The filling has big knots and the only way I don’t end up with my face falling through the stuffing is to wad it up into a tiny little knot."
• "The foam particles, meant to replace feathers, made a mess when trying to remove some of its innards, as recommended by the manufacturer."
• "Pillow came tightly wrapped in heavy plastic, apparently from the factory. After opening, the pillow gradually filled out, as they do. Hawk eyed Wife spotted a small rip in the outer cover."
• "The xtreme comforts pillow tended to be uncomfortably hard in places where it had been compressed for long periods of time, which wasn't a problem with the coop home goods pillow."
• "I ordered the minimum thickness pillow and it was still far too thick, lumpy, rigid."

Odor

Pros:

• "I heard abt this pillow on Wirecutter. This pillow has been wonderful for me. There was no smell whatsoever."
• "After several days/a few weeks, I don't even notice an odor anymore."
• "That did away with most of the odor; enough so that I have not noticed any odor while sleeping on the pillow."
• "I can report that I found absolutely no chemical smell and once the pillow took it's shape after shipping it was ready for a good night's sleep."
• "The smell dissipated so quickly it didn’t bother me."
• "It had no odor."
• "I saw some reviews that mentioned a chemical smell when first opening, but I didn’t have that experience whatsoever."

Cons:

• "However, they are quite stinky! The chemical smell is concerning."
• "Yes, it has a strong chemical smell when it arrives."
• "The off gassing was terrible and I had to leave them in my closet for months."
• "Pillow had an unpleasant chemical smell the first few days, but that has dissipated."
• "This fourth one is very clean, like the others, but definitely has a chemical smell."
• "Absolutely unacceptable that such a toxic product can be sold in 2023. The smell is absolutely repulsive."
• "It took weeks of washing and airing out to get rid of the horrible smell coming from this pillow."

Customer Service

Pros:

• "The SELLER should give the option to return the pillow free of charge and they will resend one FREE OF CHARGE to you that has the appropriate openings to remove the shredding."
• "I promptly got a response back and they directed me to return it via amazon."
• "I contacted customer support via email regarding a few questions I had, and their response time was immediate, and the willingness to help was 110%!!!"

Cons:

• "Please don’t lie in your descriptions, now you’re getting back an opened pillow that you can’t resell."
• "I tried to contact the company but there is no contact info. The website is taken down."
• "I contacted customer service to see if that was normal, and to see if they could send additional fill to make the pillow match the description, and they just told me to return the pillow to Amazon if I wasn’t happy with it."
• "It’s been weeks and I haven’t heard back from them."
• "I can’t return it because I don’t have the original wrapper. Waste of money. Boo."