Gildan Fitted Cotton T Shirt 2 Pack Reviews Summary

Quality and Material

Pros:

• "Gildan is a very good brand... these hold up well and launder well."
• "The shirt seems of decent quality, but this one said “tear away tag for custom comfort” and when I tore the tag along the perforated dots, it ripped the seam and now it’s unraveling around the neckline."
• "Just a good solid, inexpensive T shirt."
• "The material and fit is great, except for the length. These seem VERY short compared to other shirts, even other guildan shirts."
• "The black color is a nice dark black."
• "These shirts are really comfortable and well worth the price."
• "Great looking colors, good fit and very soft/comfortable."

Cons:

• "The fabric itself is extremely thin and I would suggest you buy the next size up from what you would typically wear."
• "These t-shirts are crap. First of all, it's small for a 3X and actually quite short. I like to sleep in large shirts and this one isn't even as long as my other 2X shirts."
• "You can see daylight through these shirts."
• "These are not the 90% cotton 10% polyester like they should be. Are extremely small and have literally zero stretch."
• "There's a strange bulge/extrude in left shoulder which is the defect during manufacturing maybe from cutting the cloth."
• "Strange, awkward, and uncomfortable cut in the shoulder, sleeve, and underarm area."
• "Both shirts I received had loose stitching on the neck."

Fit and Comfort

Pros:

• "Fit was right on as described, shirts are fairly light weight which makes them great for wearing under other shirts or sweaters."
• "The XL fit like a glove in all the right places, just snug enough around my upper body without showing off my dad bod belly."
• "I’m 6.0 and 185 lbs and a MEDIUM fits me perfectly."
• "So I got the xxxl navy heather and they fit great."
• "Ordered Medium and they fit great."
• "I’m about 5’10 180lbs , athletic build and a size Medium was perfect .. not tight, but not loose."
• "I’m curvy and tall.. I ordered the large ., fits me perfect or they way I hoped it would .. soft, not clingy , long ., comfortable!"

Cons:

• "The material and fit is great, except for the length. These seem VERY short compared to other shirts, even other guildan shirts."
• "The light gray is no where near as good as the dark gray or gray blue .they are different material more cotton and baggy not fitted horrible I use them as rags."
• "Sadly the color on the site doesn't look at all the same in person. It is considerably lighter."
• "When I got this product I was pretty excited right out of the bag it fit pretty well but after one wash on a cold cycle the shirt shrunk to the point where I can’t even wear it. definitely not happy with this product!"
• "The solid color shirts are 100% cotton and once washed they shrunk so much I can’t wear them because they aren’t long enough now."
• "This darker gray was short in the torso and then after washing shrank a ton making it completely unusable."
• "The material is super soft. The length was actually fine on him, but the shoulders and arms were muscle ripping tight."

Customer Service and Shipping

Pros:

• "T-shirts were great, but delivery time was not. After explaining the details to ShopOnLine, they resolved the issue to my satisfaction."
• "Gildan went above and beyond my expectations to address the problems with the shirts and have fully restored my faith in the company."
• "Came quickly and was perfect for what I needed!"
• "Although when this product was shipped it came super fast and the T-shirts are great quality and super soft the pictures on the listing are not very reliable."
• "These shirts definitely fit the bill and I would purchase more the next time I decide to go on another vacation."

Cons:

• "Buyer beware. The listing is for TWO shirts, I only received one."
• "I tried contacting Amazon as I would have to go out of my way to drop of the returns and they didn't want to provide free ups pickup."
• "I really like the fit and and feel of the shirts but the Amazon label on the product indicates that it is a two pack but I was only sent one t shirt. In defense of the company I think this is a listing error."
• "I ordered a two-pack and received one shirt. A very nice shirt. But one is not two and a 2-pack should not contain one...even a very nice one. The company response was that I got what I ordered, which is twice the insult."
• "They just didn't want to honor the advertised price. DO NOT order from this company."
• "The item said a case of 72 shirts and I only received one shirt. I would not have ordered this item if I knew it was only a single shirt. False information."
• "The first thing I noticed was the shirts weren’t wrapped in their own packaging, they were placed directly in the shipping bag."

Color and Appearance

Pros:

• "The black color is a nice dark black."
• "Great looking colors, good fit and very soft/comfortable."
• "Very soft and stretchy! A nice orange color that is slightly 'heathered' and I would describe it as a sherbert color."
• "I'm also quite satisfied with the blue color."
• "The color is awesome, the shirt is soft and the fit is perfect."
• "The red and green are nice, not as quite as soft as I'd hoped, but the white is slightly see through."
• "These shirts have an amazing feel and very soft, but I think the color scheme is off. I ordered sapphire and received turquoise…"

Cons:

• "Sadly the color on the site doesn't look at all the same in person. It is considerably lighter."
• "However I ordered the Heather blue and it came a completely different shade of blue."
• "Wanted a darker green as in the ad but this is what I got."
• "The picture must be the incorrect picture for the color which stinks."
• "Only negative comment is color was not what you’d expected for red, rather it is a heather pink/coral."
• "Most colors were as presented, except the sapphire I would consider turquoise."
• "The new colors came today and they aren't the same shirt."