Pepperidge Farm Goldfish Multipack Savory Reviews Summary

Flavor Variety

Pros:

• "The plus is that this variety box has the Pretzel flavor!"
• "I love that it's a variety pack and you get a few different ones."
• "There are three different flavors and the pretzel one is actually the best."
• "These snacks are tasty and not bland non-descript flavor of the regular cheddar goldfish!"
• "Each flavor provides a unique and enjoyable snacking experience, catering to different taste preferences."
• "All three flavors are excellent & the portion size is excellent for a quick snack."
• "These are AWESOME!! We didn’t even know they came in Rainbow colors!"

Cons:

• "Didn't like the 'colors' kind, I can taste the vegetable flavoring."
• "The Pretzels are tough and a bit stale."
• "What happened to the cheddar flavor??? Decades ago I bought these for my children when they were small. They Loved them, I loved them, so I came across this deal and Thought I would get them. THEY TASTE, just a Little, more flavorful than an oyster cracker."
• "BUT, these Goldfish do not taste as cheddary as they used to!"
• "Ok so I received exactly what was advertised so I’m not going to complain but I didn’t notice that there’s actually pretzel goldfish which I don’t like."
• "I bought these for my daughters school for class snacks. the outside of the box looks as described but inside it was just the regular flavor. No rainbow or pretzel flavors."
• "The pretzel goldfish are oversalted."

Freshness & Quality

Pros:

• "They are always fresh and in good physical condition (not smashed up)."
• "They came in a big box they were all individually packed and were fresh."
• "The most for the price. The product was fresh, nice portion size & flavor was like it was supposed to be...nice & cheesy."
• "These are great snacks! They are really fresh, fresher than what I can buy in the grocery store. I like the selection of flavors, too."
• "They arrived fresh, crispy, and with that great cheddar flavor we all know and love."
• "When it came to opening each bag they were fresh and each fish was whole no crumbles."
• "Fresh and good quality product."

Cons:

• "I got this product just about a month and a half before it’s expiration date."
• "I got this product on 11/29/19, but the expiration date is 12/22/19, I am so disappointed about this, it’s less than a month of the expiration."
• "Unfortunately the box of gold fish crackers are more than a month expired."
• "I was sent 2 expired goldfish cracker boxes which were supposed to be for my sons preschool class."
• "Expired before I even purchased them according to the date."
• "We bought the Goldfish package and the package was almost outdated. It was 5 days till it expired."
• "I got expired goldfish."

Packaging & Convenience

Pros:

• "I bought these for traveling in my RV when we need a light snack. Just the right amount & very tasty."
• "Always a favorite in my house love that it's so easy to order and not have to worry about leaving with two kids and the trouble of traffic and rude employees."
• "I'm a very big fan of portion control, especially whenever it comes to snacks."
• "These were perfect to put into goody bags, sack lunches and as an on-the-go snack."
• "The individual bags makes it easy to grab a snack or add to a school lunch."
• "I like the individual packaging for portion control."
• "These Goldfish come 6 to a case. I always have some on hand for visits from my grandkids & for my own snack attacks where nothing else will quite work."

Cons:

• "Goldfish are goldfish, you always know what to expect. These were shipped with heavy bottles and arrived smashed."
• "2 of the 30 bags were popped open."
• "This supposed box of 20 only came with 18. They were meant to serve as a snack for a preschool class of 20 so obviously this was a big problem."
• "I bought the 30 pack mix. The box was unopened, but when I opened it there were no pretzel goldfish. I was missing 8 of the 30 bags of goldfish."
• "They came rotten and all crashed up they were also stale they were awful won’t even rate a 1 star."
• "The biggest shortcoming of the packaging is the foil lining inside the container."
• "The box came torn and beat up opened."

Value for Money

Pros:

• "This was a great value for the size. In the grocery store it was $2.50 more per box."
• "I only get these when they are under $6 per box."
• "Bought two and even got a discount with a simple click on the computer."
• "Then he told me they were only $6.85 and my jaw hit the floor."
• "This same box, which brings countless joy to a family of 5 or any kids party or just a lazy Thursday night like mine here, is normally easily 12+ dollars even at your local Walmart."
• "It was an amazing purchase and it was definitely worth the mere $15 I paid."
• "The price is better here then the store. Will keep buying from here instead."

Cons:

• "I was very disappointed that it was such an old date. I will hesitate to order again."
• "GREAT FOR GIVING, BUT CAN'T BECAUSE IT IS TWO MONTHS OUT."
• "This is the worst amazon purchase I have ever made, they were dated for 2020...they expired 11/08/2020 and tasted like cardboard."
• "The price was fair (I thought at first), but the product was such a large amount, that I hoped it would have had a further out expiration date."
• "Each pack is ridiculously small and is 1 ounce. ALSO the price on the box says $10.99. I bought these for my class as a snack during their testing. What a waste."
• "I bought these on April 26th and they have July as an expiration date!!!😠"
• "Kind of disappointed….I ordered these for Valentine’s Day and they were delivered back on Feb 9th. I just noticed, when collapsing the box, that the sell by date is December 17, 2023."