Silicone Kitchen Reusable Baking Cups Reviews Summary

Quality and Durability

Pros:

• "Good quality, muffins slide right out."
• "These baking cups are very sturdy and well made. My other silicone baking cups are much thinner and have teared over time."
• "These are AMAZING! Really good quality, they fit perfectly in my large muffin tins, and super easy to clean."
• "These are sturdy enough when filled to stand on their own on a baking sheet."
• "They're reusable and last forever."
• "These are really sturdy - have had them for awhile now and they are in great shape still."
• "These cups are super easy to clean. I have cooked egg cups and cupcakes in them and the food just slides right out without leaving any residue."

Cons:

• "These are not 100% silicone....Be nice to see what % or silicone it is made of and what % of fillers and what type of filler they use on them...."
• "After one use the baking cups are stained permanently."
• "Only kind of nonstick without oil or spray- expect a thin layer of cake left on the silicon."
• "I regretted buying these. While they are beautiful and reusable, it is HARD to get the cake out without it crumbling."
• "Did first batch of muffins at usual temp. When center cooked bottoms were burned. Next time reduced temp 50 degrees. Same issue. Trashed cups."
• "Unfortunately these are not oven safe - after the first time I baked muffins with these, they discolored to a brown shade in places as pictured."
• "These silicone muffin holders were too thick in my opinion. It makes them a little inflexible and it was hard to get my muffins out without breaking them."

Cleaning and Maintenance

Pros:

• "Super easy to wash in the top rack of dishwasher."
• "Easy to clean: turn inside out and scrub ridges with a brush, pop them into the top rack of the dishwasher."
• "They release cleanly and are sturdy enough to run through the dishwasher so I don't have to scrape bits of food out of all the little crevices."
• "Hold up great. Clean easily - just toss in the dishwasher."
• "These silicone liners are easy to clean - pop them on upper level of dishwasher, and easy to pop out muffins."
• "These clean really well in the dishwasher."
• "Sturdy, easy to clean either by hand or in the dishwasher."

Cons:

• "They are a little difficult to clean all the folds."
• "Cleaning them is not a dip, rinse, & done and more of a soak in soapy water for several minutes and use a gentle toothbrush to get all the stuff out of the pleated sides."
• "A little bit hard to clean but just soak in warm water and use a brush scrubber."
• "Hand cleaning is not difficult but can be a little labor intensive to get all the crevices x 12."
• "We loved these at first, but after a few weeks of use (washing them in the top rack of the dishwasher) we noticed our muffins started tasting soapy."
• "The little cup cake crumbs were in the crevices and I couldn't for the life of me get them out."
• "They are a bit hard to clean. I have to soak them first and then put them in the dishwasher."

Size and Fit

Pros:

• "I think they're a perfect fit for my muffin pan."
• "These are actual jumbo liners."
• "These work great and fit perfectly in my standard muffin pan."
• "I love the size of these! They hold a lot of batter without overflowing when they bake."
• "Well these do fit in my jumbo muffin pan however they also fit in the holes in my standard size muffin pan, they are just a bit taller."
• "They fit well in our jumbo muffin cooking sheets."
• "I have a 24 piece mini muffin tin and was looking for silicon baking cups that would fit."

Cons:

• "Those are way too big for the muffin tin. The standard size needs to be fixed so that it actually fits a standard muffin tin."
• "These are soooo wonderful ... but so small. Need larger, jumbo sizes."
• "Cute cups a little thin though and are only 2 inches if you stretch them out so if you really need 2 inches then you may want to reconsider!"
• "I ordered the standard size and they were way too small for my standard muffin tin."
• "The bottom of these silicone liners is much smaller than the bottom of the holes in my jumbo muffin pan."
• "These are horrible. They are slightly smaller than regular sized muffin tins, which is annoying."
• "These liners were smaller than the size of standard muffin tin cups, leaving a gap between the liner and the muffin tin cup."

Design and Aesthetics

Pros:

• "They were packaged beautifully."
• "I love these for their size and muted colors."
• "Also very pretty."
• "Love that these are eco-friendly and available in these pretty colors."
• "I really like the colors of these little silicone muffin cups."
• "Really cute cupcake/muffin liners that come in nice colors which is great in terms of presentation."
• "Much cuter color set than other brands."

Cons:

• "The other muffin baking cups I have are nice, but in really bright colors which, eh, I'm not trying to have an aesthetic kitchen, but they are an eyesore nonetheless."
• "Though it makes it harder to tell my kids hey the one you want is the light sage one."
• "The colors are nice because yes, they’re a little more “stylish” than the brightly colored ones that are offered."
• "I think I only got eleven of these :(The colors are very pretty, but I feel like the white ones kind of stick out awkwardly."
• "These are fine. The colors match the on-line images, but I found them a tad small."
• "I only wish they had smooth sided the ridges are a little inconvenient to clean."
• "This is my second set of silicone muffin cups and while they are thicker material everything sticks to them."