Julep Pencil Long Lasting Waterproof Eyeliner Reviews Summary

Application & Texture

Pros:

• "It goes on so smooth and stays put- even through my allergies."
• "What I like most about this eyeliner is how easy it is to apply. Most pencil type liners pull or drag. This does neither! It glides on easily and lasts."
• "This I pencil goes on very smoothly. No tugging, no having to apply it back-and-forth."
• "It's smooth & easy to apply with just the right amount of shimmer."
• "It goes on very smoothly and looks great."
• "Goes on super smooth and seemed to stay put."
• "This stuff is wonderful. Not only does it go on easily, but it wears wonderfully."

Cons:

• "It smears going on, to the point of getting on the pencil itself."
• "Not really happy with this purchase. The eye pencil material flakes off as you are putting it on."
• "The eyeliner is really soft and it's difficult to get a tight line."
• "It smeared all down beneath my lower lid."
• "It also smeared under my eyes and didn’t want to stay on water line."
• "It goes on ok, but feels like was... smudges in a few hours."
• "This liner was very difficult to apply. Too soft, messy, smeared after application."

Longevity

Pros:

• "Stays all day, no smudging."
• "It doesn’t smudge and actually stays on throughout an 8hr workday."
• "I was pleasantly surprised that this stays put. Tested through overnight and the next morning it was still there."
• "This eyeliner lasts really well and does not smudge or smear."
• "This waterproof eyeliner goes on smooth (no tugging on eyelids) and stays put all day long."
• "It stayed on all day."
• "This pencil is waterproof and lasts all day. The application is very smooth with great pigment."

Cons:

• "Bought this in the hopes it would stay put on my (admittedly greasy) upper eyelid. Smudged within minutes of application."
• "After applying to my top lids, it was running all the way down beneath my eyes within 2 hours."
• "It did not smear or smudge. Long lasting but believe me it is so hard to sharpen if you can at all!"
• "Within a few hours it smudged all over and is definitely not waterproof."
• "By 9 am the eyeliner is smudged under the eyes."
• "It smeared all down beneath my lower lid."
• "It also smeared under my eyes and didn’t want to stay on water line."

Sharpening & Product Design

Pros:

• "I do agree that this Julep makeup sharpener does its job really well in sharpening my lip liners without eating them so much since it doesn’t break the tip so easily like other sharpeners tend to do."
• "I purchased this pencil sharpener because it is for gel eye pencils, and it is PERFECT! It sharpens to a sharp point."
• "This sharpener is a great value! It works every time."
• "My gel pencil sharpens really nicely with this sharpener and I love that there is no bending over a trashcan while sharpening."
• "This sharpener works perfectly with the Julep eye liner pencils."
• "This Julep sharpener puts a point on the pencil better than new."
• "This sharpener is worth every penny. It smoothly and evenly sharpened all of my pencils."