SureGuard Mattress Protectors Crib Size Reviews Summary

Fit and Size

Pros:

• "It fits our new cal king foam mattress perfectly and tightly."
• "Fit my Cali King mattress perfectly, even the thickness was deep enough to go down to the bottom corners."
• "The protector fits the mattress well."
• "It fits our queen size mattress well, with no excessive wrinkles to have to smooth out."
• "It fits very securely, which I was worried about since my mattress is very deep."
• "It fit the twin mattress perfectly (standard US-based twin mattress)."
• "It is a perfect fit on my queen-size Tempurpedic mattress."

Cons:

• "On our adjustable beds they tend to become 'rump sprung' after a few years."
• "I do like the fact that this mattress protector doesn't move like some of the other mattresses. However, it is a little too short overall. It should protect well over the mattress but it does fall short by appx. 2 inches on all sides."
• "Mattress protector doesn’t fit our standard 12” deep mattress well. It is too loose, resulting in extra fabric which has the tendency of bunching up underneath the sheets."
• "The corners lift constantly and the sides are generally exposed."
• "First, it’s advertised as a deep pocket cover and it does not fit around my 14 inch mattress completely."
• "It fits poorly, as did the first one."
• "I'm concerned that it is going to lose its fit."

Waterproof Quality

Pros:

• "Launders well and the only spill (water) did not get through the mattress cover."
• "It’s super soft and easy to roll onto the bed. The best part is it’s water proof so you don’t have to worry about it soaking everything right up."
• "So far, it has held up very well to several washes and is certainly waterproof."
• "Old mattress cover needed replacing for mattress protection. This is ample size for big mattress, moisture resistant (tested it with a pint of water poured on), spent a lot of time selecting this one, love it."
• "When tested for water repellence, did well. I poured several cups of water on it and none went through."
• "Each one has been 'tested' with spills. They've done their job."
• "After reading reviews I felt confident purchasing this waterproof mattress protector. It fits our deep king size mattress perfectly and doesn’t shrink after washing. It definitely protects against accidents."

Cons:

• "They are not completely water proof."
• "I expected more as these are part of a three sheet rotation and they only lasted 10 months before they started to leak through to the mattress."
• "I then did a water test and water went right through, within seconds."
• "Update: On 10/30, this product failed again; junk. I have discovered this product is only suitable for one use and cannot be washed."
• "It has leaked through several times and I would have to say while it doesn't make noise when we are sleeping on it, it also is not waterproof and is, therefore, useless."
• "So disappointed. Bought this for my 3 year old who still has the occasional accident in the night. It leaked right through to the mattress."
• "Definitely not waterproof. My cat peed on the bed, so I stripped the bedding to wash it. Sure enough, pee had gotten on the mattress."

Comfort and Noise

Pros:

• "These wash up nicely and I'm very happy with my purchase!"
• "I also like that I washed it once and it still looks like new."
• "Doesn’t have that ‘crinkly’ Mouse like many others do."
• "I am extremely pleased with this product."
• "I found it comfortable and was not bothered at all by any noise from the protector."
• "It is a very soft mattress pad and does not make a noise when you move on it."
• "Very comfortable and soft."

Cons:

• "My problem is that it is hot to sleep on."
• "The SureGuard was the only one of the three that slept so hot."
• "This mattress protector makes you sleep incredibly HOT."
• "But is it noiseless? No."
• "It does not make any crinkly sounds at all."
• "There is absolutely no noise from the pad when my husband shifts his body."
• "The item right out of the package has a very plastic feel and sound."