Bedding Premium Waterproof Mattress Protector Reviews Summary

Material and Comfort

Pros:

• "It is also made of a very nice and soft terry material, which actually adds to the comfort when sleeping."
• "The mattress protector isn’t crunchy like other ones I have purchased."
• "It’s very soft and actually made my bed feel even more comfortable unlike plastic mattress protectors."
• "The skirting is beautiful material, not at all paperlike, as some of them are & it actually fits under the mattress, result!!"
• "The top is very soft, and it isn't even noticeable with a sheet over it."
• "The material is soft to the touch and it is substantial--not flimsy at all."
• "It’s soft and smooth yet waterproof."

Cons:

• "I really dislike the towel-like material. It's like 15 year old, thin, worn out towel material."
• "Soft to the touch but that is about the only positive. I have never sweat like I have before."
• "I am so glad I slept on this bed before a guest did—this mattress cover is super sweat-inducing."
• "Material is thin, too stretchy. After fighting to get it on the mattress, could not get it smooth."
• "Okay. I feel like this was made in a sweatshop and I don’t think I’ve ever felt that way in my life. The quality is cheap and terrible, the seams are sewn absolutely awfully."
• "The upper texture is similar to a towel, so you feel like you're sleeping on a towel, unless you add another layer on top."
• "Where this product lost a star for me was in how poorly it breathes."

Waterproof Effectiveness

Pros:

• "It's been tested with both water and pee (from my toddler), and the mattress has stayed dry."
• "Bought this for my 2 year old who has transitioned into her twin bed, but isn't night time potty trained. She's had a couple of accidents, but not a drop has made it though to her mattress."
• "The waterproof mattress cover by Utopia is well made and much more substantial than the other mattress cover I had on the bed."
• "This will not let the water, or whatever liquid spilled, through."
• "No leak through to mattresses of any body fluids."
• "This protector has done its job- my dogs have thrown up and peed on my bed, and every time I peel off this protector, my mattress is dry and clean."
• "Did not leak through the protector on the mattress."

Cons:

• "I've only had it 'leak' when my daughter wet the bed and didn't tell me for a few hours."
• "But I’ve had it for just over a month now. And it doesn’t do anything. Nighttime bed wedding goes right through into the mattress."
• "It has been leaking all summer, every time my son has an accident at night."
• "Leaks through to mattress."
• "This is not a Waterproof mattress cover... the mattress is ruined."
• "Even the smallest pee will leak through to the mattress."
• "Used it, but it was not waterproof at all!!!!"

Durability and Maintenance

Pros:

• "I bought a $40 zippered mattress protector and this one is far better."
• "Purchasing my third mattress protector from this company! We have a toddler and I have bought protectors in the past that cost 5 times this price!"
• "I used while potty training 2 children and never had a leak onto the mattress."
• "You understand how good a mattress protector is when you wash them regularly. Not only does this item do the job but also holds up very nicely."
• "I have been using it for 6 months so far, and washed more than 5 times but it doesn't get ripped! High quality!"
• "We've had our oldest one of these over 3 years and it's held up perfectly through the typical washings."
• "I have washed this mattress pad 3x and it looks great."

Cons:

• "The plasticky waterproof interior is starting to crack?? though- probably from the washing and drying."
• "After I placed them on the mattress a hole was clearly visible on one set & and long run/tear on the set."
• "I have washed these ONCE and... it completely SOAKED through and destroyed our mattress."
• "The first wash was fine. The plastic was all stuck together after the second wash and I threw them out."
• "Some mattress pads... have shrunk, melted, gotten crooked or fallen apart after a single wash."
• "After just a few washes, the plastic waterproof backing is starting to deteriorate."
• "I got really upset to see a hole in the protector after I washed it and as I was folding it... very disappointed :("

Fit and Size

Pros:

• "Fits perfectly even the pockets and it’s washable."
• "Fits perfectly on my T&N twin mattress. It doesn’t bunch or bulge, stays taut."
• "Fits well on my deep mattress with room to tuck it in."
• "It fit perfectly, with little effort required to stretch it over the corners."
• "It fit out tempurpedic queen bed perfectly."
• "This mattress protector fits my preschoolers twin bed perfectly."
• "Fits the bed perfectly and stays on the mattress, despite a lot of rolling/flipping/flopping from the occupants of the bed!"

Cons:

• "All our mattresses have a waterproof protector. I bought a king size, when we got a new pillow top mattress. It is great waterproof on the top, but it doesn’t have smooth grip on sides, doesn't have deep pockets for high mattresses."
• "The only issue is that it’s a little tight and hard to get on my queen size mattress."
• "My complaint with them is that they are a little baggy on the thin bunkbed mattresses, which means they slide around a little."
• "I’m not sure if it’s designed to be like that or possibly just too small."
• "It's super easy to tear or break through as you try to stretch it over the corners of the mattress."
• "The border/corners material is so thin that when trying to pull over the corner for fit, my finger actually pierced a small hole in the fabric."
• "I ordered twin size, and it doesn’t nearly fit my son’s twin size mattress!"