Makeup Melt Cleansing Balm Remover Reviews Summary

Effectiveness

Pros:

• "It cleans all my makeup completely off."
• "Melts my makeup including mascara and brow gel right off with no residue or greasiness."
• "It emulsified the makeup, washes off cleanly, and all that without scrubbing."
• "Removes ALL makeup, waterproof mascara, magnetic eyeliner. I haven't found anything this doesn't remove."
• "This cleansing balm just lifts everything off your skin and makes it rinse off like butter."
• "It melts off all the makeup off your face, even waterproof mascara."
• "This product is excellent at removing makeup, sunscreen and waterproof mascara all at once."

Cons:

• "This product is great at the beginning of cleansing but it doesn’t rinse like other balms I’ve tried."
• "I felt like it did not take off my make up, so I followed up with soap."
• "This cleansing balm does not clean off makeup properly, especially mascara!"
• "Its ok, but has a very hard time with liquid eyeliner and waterproof mascaras."
• "Every time I used this balm I ended up still removing eye makeup and mascara with another separate makeup remover. Doesn't work."
• "It was ok but didn't really take off mascara well regular, or Waterproof."
• "It does not do a great job dissolving my makeup."

Skin Feel & Sensitivity

Pros:

• "It’s moisturizing and it works great on my sensitive skin."
• "This one has a very buttery feel to it and did not dry out my skin at all."
• "I have sensitive skin and ultra-sensitive eyes, this has been gentle and wonderful to both."
• "It does not irritate my eyes (no blurry film or odor) or rosacea-prone skin."
• "This balm leaves my skin soft and supple without a greasy residue or clogging up my pores."
• "I have super sensitive skin and when using the product there was no irritation."
• "There is no scent which I love as I have very sensitive skin."

Cons:

• "Unfortunately, my skin has become hypersensitive in the last few months and my skin had a terrible reaction on my neck (red and inflamed) after using this twice as part of my nighttime routine."
• "However, this seems to make my skin irritable and dry."
• "It leaves a bit of a oily film on my face."
• "However it’s extremely heavy and greasy and leaves a lard like residue. Don’t recommend at all."
• "I don’t think I would buy this again though since I’m not sure if it actually does anything."
• "It leaves behind a thick, oily feeling."
• "It burns and my eyes continue tearing even after it's washed off."

Packaging & Size

Pros:

• "I liked the packaging, I thought it was clean and simple to understand."
• "The packaging ink kept smudging to the point where its completely gone now. It makes the product feel cheap."
• "The sizing is not what I expected, the bottle is very small."
• "The product arrived leaked and the sticker was all oily."
• "The packaging on this product is cheap."
• "The only thing is that the ink on the jar will rub off but honestly as long as you know what it is its fine."
• "Love the product but the container’s print is making a mess every time I pick it up. The logo and words are coming off and leaving streaks of black on my fingers and anything I touch."

Cons:

• "The perfect makeup remover."
• "Grace & Stella cleansing balm is the winner so far!"
• "So happy to have found this and compared to the others, it is your best option financially."
• "Best price per ounce that I've found too."
• "The price point is great and I will definitely reorder!"
• "Another excellent recommendation by my Skincare Guru Angie (YouTuber - Hot & Flashy)."
• "Price is better on this balm plus there is more product."

Value & Price

Pros:

• "So happy to have found this and compared to the others, it is your best option financially."
• "Best price per ounce that I've found too."
• "The price point is great and I will definitely reorder!"
• "It’s priced right, the product lasts forever, AND cruelty free. Worth every penny."
• "Price per ounce is the best value I've found."
• "The price of this balm is also quite a bit less than 'the other one'."
• "You get a lot for the price and it removes my makeup."

Cons:

• "The product arrived leaked and the sticker was all oily."
• "The sizing is not what I expected, the bottle is very small."
• "The 60 ml is quite small. It is less than half the size of the 5 oz."
• "Price is higher then the other kind I use. The price has go up $1.00 since I bought it 2 weeks ago most likely I'll go back to my old brand."
• "I have nearly an entire container that's going to waste so I'm pretty disappointed."
• "Unfortunately I wasn’t able to use the scan code to get the free gift offered."
• "I will finish the jar but make sure to double cleanse with another cleanser, and will not purchase again."