Classic Mascara Cabaret Premiere Cruelty Reviews Summary

Application & Texture

Pros:

• "It does coat very well in just one coat and makes my lashes look thicker than they actually are."
• "The mascara glides on so smoothly. No clumps and didn’t smudge at all."
• "I love how smooth the texture and consistency is, and the dainty brush is an excellent shape for hitting every lash!"
• "It spreads evenly. The brush arranges my lashes perfectly and the mascara applies evenly and smoothly to give me the look that I want."
• "It separates very nicely and the applicator wand doesn’t get too dirty."
• "The brush is small with tiny combs, therefore, it eliminates all the excess mascara that ends up looking clumpy on the eyeline."
• "It lifts and separates, NO CLUMPS.."

Cons:

• "I wore it for 7hrs and this is literally the most flaky mascara I've ever used in my life."
• "But it doesn’t stay, it falls and flakes and leaves me with dark heavy eyes."
• "The product makes lashes go flat or down after curling and clumps with one coat."
• "Hard to remove, not consistent and lashes looks uneven after application."
• "It’s a very wet product, with a skimpy applicator and my lashes clumped together after applying it."
• "The brush is horrible and the consistency of the mascara is thick and chunky."
• "It feels like the formula is dried out and it's difficult to apply without lashes clumping together."

Longevity & Removal

Pros:

• "Doesn't smudge AT All, even after 14 hours of wear."
• "This product stays on, does not smudge, and gives a great finished look to your lashes."
• "It doesn't smudge, and comes off easily for me with soap and water."
• "This one does not flake or run. No racoon eyes for me with this."
• "Doesn't flake, even after 14 hours of wear."
• "It comes off with soap and water."
• "No clumps, great definition, stays all day, no smudges and easy to wash off."

Cons:

• "Could you provide information on how to remove it? Having a difficult time!"
• "However it holds pretty well for most of the day but if you're going out at night too you'll need to reapply."
• "Loved the application and no clumping but heck if this stuff is hard to take off at night."
• "It's really hard to remove this mascara and it's a little messy to put on."
• "Was a little difficult to remove even after a full face wash and makeup remover routine."
• "This is a very hard mascara to remove."
• "It’s super smudgy, end up with flakes in my eyes and black all under my eyes."

Effect & Look

Pros:

• "Will continue to buy this brand after being loyal to great lash for the last 15 years."
• "The brush on this is amazing and it extends the lash!"
• "This is the FIRST mascara that has given me lush, long, separated lashes!"
• "This mascara does the job! It makes my eyelashes longer, adds volume and curls."
• "Both shades, black and brown, are beautiful."
• "This works so much better than the common brands that promise full and longer lashes but rarely deliver."
• "The brush is the right size and is easy to get my smaller lower eye lashes."

Cons:

• "It doesn't add fullness or length to your lashes."
• "It’s not that long or voluminous. I was hoping for dramatic lashes and I did not get that."
• "The tube did not seem to last as long as some of the others."
• "As soon as I open the tube I can tell- it’s more gray as opposed to the dark black and the consistency is thicker than the Caberet I’ve loved. It’s also flaking which was never an issue I had with this mascara."
• "It came really dry and the brush is small. It also irritates my eyes."
• "She LOVES IT! it is very lengthening and you can keep layering to build your lashes."
• "Within a few weeks after opening, product begins to clump on lashes."