Nordic Ware Natural Aluminum Commercial Reviews Summary

Durability and Quality

Pros:

• "They clean up beautifully after use and haven’t warped in the slightest."
• "They are sturdy, even heating & easy to clean."
• "These are absolutely phenomenal sheet pans!"
• "These baking sheets are lightweight, but they don't warp in the oven like my old ones do."

Cons:

• "It did have its imperfections (bunch of scratches on the bottom)."
• "However, they let off a strange smell for about 15 minutes the first time in the oven at 425°."
• "I received scratched pans. One was scratched in the original order and one was scratched in the replacement order."
• "The pan pitted and there are quite a few spots that turned white from the grease."

Non-Stick Performance and Cleanup

Pros:

• "So far nothing has gotten stuck to the pan (it's aluminum, not a non-stick coated pan)."
• "These are not you toss after a year. These pans will last a lifetime. Has solid weight that won't warp and EXTREMELY affordable."
• "They work just like advertised. After a single use for cooking bacon, the pan pitted and there are quite a few spots that turned white from the grease."

Cons:

• "These do not come clean without something like SOS scouring pads at minimum."
• "I don't understand how everyone says how great this pan is! The cutlets stuck."
• "The fact that these pans are described as 'commercial' is laughable at best. They are made of thin gauge metal and consistently warp and bow in the oven."

Dishwasher Safety

Pros:

• "I never put them in the dishwasher, they are just so easy to clean with hand washing."

Cons:

• "I gave the sheet pans 2 stars because a product like that should be able to be DISHWASHER SAFE."
• "Soo good. Sturdy and never warped. This is my second set after a move. I will say that when I put these in the dishwasher, they came out with this nasty chemical wash look."
• "I was a bit shocked and disappointed at the discoloration after running one of these through the dishwasher."

Size and Fit

Pros:

• "This is smaller than the tray in my Cuisinart air fryer but it’s perfect to pop in if making something small and a bit easier to clean."
• "This little 1/8 sheet is perfect for small bakes -- a few chicken breasts, potatoes, or fish filets."

Cons:

• "For some reason, I didn't look at the size and thought this would be bigger. It is quite small."
• "I was excited about receiving these, opened up the package started taking them apart, first one looked good, the second one looked a little scratched but the third one the big one looks scratched and used."