Neutrogena Non Greasy Waterproof Dermatologist Ophthalmologist Reviews Summary

Effectiveness

Pros:

• "It works as well or better as the other one and is a fraction of the cost!!"
• "It's the best for getting off stubborn mascara and glitter without a ton of rubbing."
• "Even removes waterproof mascara."
• "This is an incredible product that removes every bit of eye make up!"
• "It takes off even my waterproof makeup with ease and does not irritate my sensitive skin."
• "This makeup remover gets off the most stubborn makeup!"
• "It really does do what it's supposed to do."

Cons:

• "This makeup remover does get the job done, but for me, it was very messy and still felt super oily on my eyes."
• "I’m too afraid to put this on my eyes. There is no safety seal inside or out."
• "Pro's-Lots of product. Large bottle. Inexpensive.Con's-Doesn't work well on waterproof mascara."
• "Both bottles came unsealed and I did use it but it’s not removing my eye make up like Neutrogena usually does I am returning very disappointed."
• "It takes a lot, and several passes with a rough touch on a cotton pad, to remove plain mascara."
• "THIS PRODUCT DOES NOT REMOVE EYE MAKEUP. NOT EVEN CLOSE."
• "It also takes a lot of rubbing to get all the make up off."

Skin Sensitivity

Pros:

• "Does not leave my face feeling oily."
• "As a person with sensitive skin, I'm always a little reluctant to try new products. With two dabs on my cotton pad, it was able to remove my entire face. It doesn't feel oily, and doesn't make me break out."
• "I have very sensitive eyes and it doesn't bother them at all like others do."
• "This remover doesn't bother my skin or eyes at all!"
• "It is perfect for sensitive skin as well."
• "I have sensitive skin and sensitive eyes. This is the best eye makeup remover that I have used."
• "Removes makeup really easily and I've never had an issue with it even though I have sensitive skin."

Cons:

• "Settled for store brand knock off once….eyes got irritated and swollen."
• "This was still oily and I had to wipe so much my under eyes were so sore."
• "Big thumbs down on this product because it gave me blepharitis (eyelash infection) and then pink eye."
• "Also, my eyes puff up by morning after using it so I'm likely allergic to this 'sensitive skin' formula."
• "However the makeup remover does burn my eyes a lot and recently, I’ve woken up with crusts formed around my eyes where I have applied the makeup remover."
• "It’s caused red rashes around my eyes and definitely hurts like hell if it accidentally goes into your eyes."
• "Works well but burns real badly if you get it in your eyes."

Texture and Residue

Pros:

• "Feels slightly greasy but washes off just fine."
• "The after-feeling is one of almost using a face oil/cream and is pleasant."
• "It’s less oily but still takes everything off."
• "This oil-free version is super gentle, non-greasy, non-stinging, non-irritating."
• "It doesn't leave any remaining 'greasy' feel and doesn't irritate my eyes at all."
• "Leaves no greasy residue at all!!!"
• "It’s sensitive enough but it doesn’t irritate my eyes and I don’t feel like I have oil left over."

Cons:

• "Honestly, it removes the make up right off. I just did not like how it felt so oily afterwards."
• "It does leave an oily residue, but I'm sure most people (like me) wash their face with cleanser after they take their makeup off to remove the oily feeling."
• "Why is that? Mary Kay's makeup remover is the same—claims to be oil free but leaves an oily residue."
• "Says oil-free and it may technically not have oils in it per se, but it is certainly oily feeling on the skin."
• "*Technically* it Might be oil free but it’s the aloe that makes it slimy, gloppy and runny."
• "It leaves strong oil residue that doesn’t allow me to reapply makeup."
• "This stuff is OILY!"

Packaging and Safety

Pros:

• "These bottles are twice the size and arrived quickly."
• "Also pack was shipped very well so got here sealed and with no leaks."
• "It was delivered perfectly with no leaks, I’ve had problems with things leaking, I like how they did this with the gripper!"
• "The packaging is attractive and durable."
• "Happy to get from Amazon in a larger size and better price."
• "We take caution when putting something close to the eyes! It is clear, not oder, non greasy. And, it removes the blackened makeup."
• "I have been a loyal consumer of this product for many many years and it always arrives with a seal at the top to ensure quality authenticity and safety."

Cons:

• "I’m too afraid to put this on my eyes. There is no safety seal inside or out."
• "It leaked everywhere when it was shipped to me."
• "The product itself is fine. However, the bottle is not sealed and by the time it arrived roughly 2/3 of the bottle had leaked out."
• "Very disappointed with this Neutrogena eye make up remover product. First of all it did not come sealed."
• "However, the bottle had no sealing packaging and leaked all over my other products in the package."
• "This amazon policy or product policy of selling bottles without safety seal should not be legal."
• "This product arrived with tape all over it — clearly seal had been broken and then it had been re-taped."

Value for Money

Pros:

• "Wonderful product and the price is great!"
• "A great price works out to be a great value."
• "This is a great value for the price as well."
• "Price is definitely cheap."
• "My local store just sells the regular size. Been looking for these and amazon has them for a great price!"
• "Great value for this 3 pack."
• "The price is reasonable. No need to look elsewhere!"