Nordic Ware Naturals Baking 2 Pack Reviews Summary

Quality and Durability

Pros:

• "These are the best baking sheets nothing else compares."
• "This is it! Heavy-duty, tolerates high heat and cleans up perfectly."
• "They’re sturdy, easy to clean, and functional."
• "Nordic Ware makes high quality aluminum products."
• "They haven’t warped at all."
• "These are thick metal, sturdy and seem like they should last."
• "You will never need to replace this pan due to warping or deterioration."

Cons:

• "Within a few washes they turned this dirty gray brown color and if you run your hand or a paper towel over them you get black residue."
• "Tray is rated to 450F. It warped substantially at 445F."
• "They come out looking bad - so heed the instructions and hand wash!!!"
• "Cheap, but doesnt do what its intended to do. So worthless."
• "They were a waste."
• "After I wash the pans by hand I usually heat them up in my oven to make sure they are completely dry as there are crevices on the folded edge that collect water."
• "I’m still a little wary about using aluminum thanks to the debunked reports of medical issues related to aluminum cooking products."

Design and Size

Pros:

• "With this larger pan, I can bake more cookies in one go, significantly cutting down my baking time."
• "It’s a good quality, large size baking sheet. It fits my oven perfectly and I have used it twice with no issues. Good value for the money."
• "Sturdy and easy to clean or cover with foil."
• "The size is perfect for sheet pan meals or doing multiple veggies to accommodate picky eaters."
• "Cooking/ and baking is always even."
• "They are the perfect size for my oven racks."
• "Loved this size sheet pan, perfect for one or two servings."

Cons:

• "Because of this it will not fit into our oven (17 inch deep max.)."
• "The large pan is NOT 17 x 12 inches but is actually 18 x 13."
• "Discoloration and significant bending came quickly to one of the two I ordered. Too large to comfortably clean in house sink."
• "The only issue you may have is where to store it due to its size!"
• "This is too big to fit into my dishwasher unfortunately."
• "The only issue is that it's big and hard to store."
• "The pan are so small for the price even for 2 pans."

Cleaning and Maintenance

Pros:

• "Keep them covered with foil so they stay pretty... these pans never fail."
• "Wipe up by hand, or put in the dishwasher."
• "They clean easily, and are nice and thick."
• "All the bacon residue slides right off like it was a non-stick pan!"
• "I bake/cook directly on these without aluminum foil, and they are easy to clean."
• "No warping at high heat, easy to clean, and feel very sturdy."
• "They cook great and clean so easily."

Cons:

• "Anyone running these through the dishwasher will quickly regret it."
• "Put 2 in the dishwasher and now they are discolored and look weird."
• "My pans got ruined on the first dishwasher cycle."
• "They become hideous after putting them through the dishwasher."
• "I see people have said after one wash in the dishwasher they discolor."
• "After less than 2 months with very infrequent use... all 3 pans have deep scratches."
• "Both of the pans stained from the meat juices."