Wilton 21 Inch 2105 0109 Perfect Non Stick Reviews Summary

Size and Capacity

Pros:

• "Yaaassss! Bigger is better. You want to cook a whole pound of bacon but don't want to use multiple cookie sheets? This solves all your problems."
• "It’s so nice to have a large sheet pan like this. It JUST fits in my gas range."
• "The big baking plate is just the right size to fill out the width and depth of my built-in double oven spaces."
• "Not only will it bake cookies but if you are into jigsaw puzzles and don't have a big enough table it can be used to hold your pieces to sort!"
• "I have 2 of these pans, which are a fantastic size for sheet pan dinners in larger families."
• "This thing is great! I use this for roasting huge piles of veggies and making several personal size pizzas at once."
• "Absolutely love the size of these cookie sheets! They fit perfectly in my oven and are so large they make cookie baking a breeze!"

Cons:

• "This thing is just too big for a typical oven, bigger isn't always better."
• "Should've paid for attention to the measurement description. It barely fits in my oven."
• "All these people leaving great reviews must own SUPER SIZED ovensI own a standard size oven. The 15 x 21 pan nearly covers the entire rack in my oven."
• "Very large cookie sheets. Unfortunately they do not fit in either my double ovens or gas range. However, they are great for cooling and using for frying."
• "This is the largest piece of cookware I will ever use. It barely fits in a standard size oven with an inch or less on each side."
• "Measure your oven. I didn’t pay attention and these just fit in mine. They don’t leave room for the heat to circulate."
• "I have a normal sized stove and it is about a half inch too long to just fit in there."

Quality and Durability

Pros:

• "The tray is well made. Sturdy. Not heavy. Non stick. Worth the investment."
• "Very durable and love the NON-Stick, fits perfectly in my oven."
• "Great baking pan, very sturdy and solid. No sharp edges, no floppiness."
• "I am happy with the non-stick coating and the higher depth of this baking sheet."
• "These pans are very large. They occupy an entire rack in our standard oven. They are also quite heavy and very sturdy."
• "They are sturdy and easy to clean. Love them!"
• "This is a huge pan that has proven to be a need when cooking for so many. It is big, easy to clean and looks nice."

Cons:

• "It severely warps at any oven temperature."
• "As others have said these pans warp after a few minutes in the oven. I would not recommend them at all."
• "At first we loved this pan and were quite happy with it but after 3 months of infrequent use it has started bending while cooking."
• "This thing deserves a zero rating...Don't buy this piece of junk!!!"
• "I have never written a review before but just felt like I wanted to let people know that this sheet tray 100% warps."
• "Buy this product and watch your food fly. I got the largest one and it warps so bad as soon as it gets hot that my chicken wings tried to fly away."
• "Under normal baking conditions, the pan will warp severely in the oven even causing a severe burn to the arms of two of my students."

Non-Stick Coating

Pros:

• "The nonstick coating keeps my tricolor corgi clean."
• "I am happy with the non-stick coating and the higher depth of this baking sheet."
• "Very durable and love the NON-Stick, fits perfectly in my oven."
• "Awesome baking sheets! So no-stick that my cookies were sliding off the pan when I took them out of the oven."
• "Non stick, big size maximizes the space in my new big oven; does roasted veggies beautifully."
• "This pan is awesome! Very easy to clean. No parchment paper needed to bake cookies."
• "The non-stick coating does its job. I do not have to spray cooking spray on it at all."

Cons:

• "I like to use us for things like roasting vegetables and such but I managed to burn two batches of cookies because of the darkness of the pan."
• "The size is great but everything burns."
• "Every cookie I ever baked on this sheet had the same problem, completely burned cookie bottoms before cookies done."
• "Do not buy this pan! It burned every single one of my cookie recipes, no matter which oven rack I put it on and even with a silicone baking mat."
• "Total crap don't waste your money unless you like eating the coating they use. Started peeling off and ending up in food 2 months in."
• "CAUTION DO NOT BUY. THESE ARE DANGEROUS."
• "I’ve only used it 4 times and now the non stick is peeling off of it and everything I bake on it burns the bottom with or without parchment paper."

Cleaning and Maintenance

Pros:

• "Easy to clean."
• "It is truly non-stick, and so cleans up easily by hand."
• "These pans are awesome! They are quite large, so I can make double batches of cookies compared to my last pans. Nothing sticks to them, so they are so easy to clean."
• "Works great, nonstick and easy to clean."
• "These clean up easily. Be sure to measure the width of your oven. These are over-sized. You can make two dozen cookies at a time!"
• "We've had two of these for several months now, no matter what is cooked on them or how bad it looks they always come clean very easily."
• "It probably won't fit in your dishwasher, but it cleans so easy that hasn't been a problem for me."

Cons:

• "This baking tray is wonky. Also after using it the first time the tray was stained."
• "This tray is so so bad! Everything gets burned underneath, it gets lopsided when exposed to heat, after a couple of months we used it, it got rusted and have stains that won’t come off."
• "The non-stick surface on these sheets is absolutely HORRIBLE. I used them only once, and I still can’t get them clean!"
• "So disappointed in this product! Looks great and cleans up easy. But in the oven it warps badly, and with so much force it throws the food."
• "The metal is very thin. This sheet pan is cheaply made and the price reflect that."
• "I wish I could give it no stars. Bought these pans so I can cook a full pound of bacon at once. Pan fits 1lb of bacon great but everything sticks and burns on these pans."
• "I purchased this baking sheet in 2022 and I was impressed by the size and weight of it when I orig. received it, but after a few uses I have been unable to clean stains that were made during baking use."

Shipping and Packaging

Pros:

• "I ordered the large baking pan and the two half-size ones, and they are all awesome."
• "This is a huge pan that has proven to be a need when cooking for so many. It is big, easy to clean and looks nice."
• "I love this pan so much I bought more for gifts. Non-stick and easy to clean."