NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Butter Non Sticky Reviews Summary

Texture & Consistency

Pros:

• "It goes on smooth and doesn't feel sticky in the slightest."
• "It feels super light on your lips and when I lick my lips, the gloss does not budge."
• "It's smooth and not tacky— I put it on my eyelids and it feels like it's barely there."
• "It is actually moisturizing and is not sticky."
• "This is not sticky at all. It's creamy and moisturizing."
• "Not at all sticky or gooey! I like the way that this glides on my lips."
• "This gloss is super smooth and buttery and keeps my lips hydrated and soft for hours."

Cons:

• "Maybe mine is just an odd one, but it is definitely sticky and not at all silky."
• "tbh, the texture is rlly thick and it dries out rlly quick.. it also leaves ur lips a bit dry."
• "It's also just feels too thick and heavy for me."
• "It’s sticky and moisturizing, with a slightly sweet cake-like scent to it."
• "When it dries it gets kinda sticky but otherwise it’s a great product for the price."
• "This was way too sticky. Hard to apply and spread."
• "It goes on gloopy and sticky."

Longevity

Pros:

• "The shine lasts for several hours."
• "This did not dry my lips out and lasted for a while."
• "Unless you eat or drink, the glossiness lasts for a significant period of time without having to reapply."
• "This gloss has serious longevity… i don’t need to reapply for 2-3 hours!"
• "I could go 4+ hours without needing to reapply."
• "It last fo hours before I have to retouch up."
• "It’s moisturizing and lasts a good three to four hours (without drinking or eating) before you have to reapply."

Cons:

• "It doesn’t last very long whatsoever. Had to keep re-applying."
• "Wears off easy."
• "It doesn’t stay on longer than 15 mins."
• "Doesn’t stay for long."
• "It doesn’t take too long before reapplying is needed."
• "However you will have to carry it with you through the night as it does fade/ rub off quickly."
• "It disappears in like half an hour if you’re lucky."

Color & Pigmentation

Pros:

• "I’m in love with the color, the consistency, and even the smell."
• "The color is buildable with each application."
• "It's a deep plum color. It can be easily layered to make the color darker which is perfect for the holidays, special occasions, or evening wear."
• "I got the shade lava cake its perfect for darker complexions."
• "This lip gloss is also the perfect nude for brown and dark skin girls 💕"
• "The vibrant hue complements various skin tones, and the glossy finish adds a touch of glam."
• "The color is exactly what I wanted and the formula feels moisturizing."

Cons:

• "But it literally shows up on me as though I’m wearing clear lipgloss."
• "The color was also subtle and I was hoping for a more pinkish color."
• "I am a medium skin tone and these just don't show up on me. It just blends in and looks like clear gloss."
• "The color lacks enough pigment so once applied it isn't as vivid as shown in pictures or even the tube itself."
• "I purchased Tiramisu (brown) and the color was not even close to what was depicted, nor did it come close to matching the color of the cap."
• "Both glosses look extremely pale in color and when layered with my lipstick gave the lipstick a grey/pale tone :( super unflattering."
• "It’s not as pink as it shows and it doesn’t last very long whatsoever."

Price & Value

Pros:

• "But it was only $4. I can’t complain too much!"
• "It’s a great product for the price and totally worth it!"
• "The price point is great."
• "And it’s a great price! Definitely recommend."
• "For the price point, this lipgloss is a great buy."
• "Plus with NYX, the price is right!"
• "Highly recommend this! It’ll work on every skin tone….and you can’t beat the low price!"

Cons:

• "Frankly disappointing. I would decline this clear gloss if NYX told me I had won a contest for it."
• "Won’t buy again….I’ll stick to COVERGIRL OUTLAST 24 HOURS ALL DAY!"
• "That crap (the Avon) went right in the trash, followed by this Nyx stuff."
• "I won't buy NYX products anymore going forward."
• "Will never buy this again, but will use it up."
• "I’m very disappointed and sorry I bought it."
• "Very unhappy!!! My product pretty much came open and there's visible dirt right by the 'closing' sticker."