Odor Eaters Ultra Durable Cushioning Insoles Reviews Summary

Fit and Comfort

Pros:

• "They were easy to cut for the sizing. I followed the guidelines that were on the soles. Fit perfectly."
• "These insoles are nice and thin. They won't make your boots fit much tighter than the normal insoles."
• "These shoe inserts are well made and provide adequate support."
• "Very comfortable and so far keeping my old, sometimes smelly, feet from permeating my immediate vicinity."
• "These are just a bit thicker than my old ones but still don’t make my shoes too tight! Great comfy product!"
• "These are a nice cushion to add to your shoe."
• "They are thick, comfortable and do the job of keeping shoes fresh."

Cons:

• "The foam LACKS STRUCTURE so trying to adjust them in your shoes is a challenge as they SCRUNCH UP while putting on your shoes."
• "They slip around in your shoes and are essentially worthless for anyone doing a significant amount of walking."
• "When inserting foot into the shoe the odor-eater moves around, difficult to position insole where it’ll stay without folding under the foot."
• "Didn't fit me. Too small."
• "Super uncomfortable I wore them for a day and through them away because of how uncomfortable they where in my boots."
• "The product is so thick it took up a lot of room inside my shoes making it very uncomfortable to walk."
• "These don’t fit well in women’s shoes, wouldn’t recommend them unless you have larger feet or are trying to put them in a sneaker or shoe with a lot of extra room."

Odor Control

Pros:

• "I place these in my work shoes and they have been the only product that stops odor."
• "Where they do excell though is eliminating odor caused by sweaty feet."
• "Definitely noticed an improvement in odor."
• "Work good for controlling odor."
• "They do exactly what they say they will do regarding odor."
• "These are great and actually DO keep the odour at bay. Also easy to cut to size."
• "Love these. My feet get super smelly even just sitting in my sneakers, and the soles on them were wearing out. After putting these in I could clearly feel the difference and smell the difference."

Cons:

• "It doesn't completely eliminate the odor; however, I might just have really smelly feet."
• "I would say it Reduces odor about 50% but does not eliminate completely."
• "They don't work. I put on my footwear at 7am, by 1:30pm my feet are smelling."
• "Not only does it not get rid or any odor, it has absolutely no traction so it constantly bunches up in my shoes."
• "Wont buy again.1) Not too sure they do so well with odor."
• "For weeks I was trying to figure out what the horrible smell was on me."
• "Within a week the inserts were worn down and my shoes back to smelling like roadkill."

Durability

Pros:

• "These aren't the cheap white Odor Eater brand that slip and wrinkle up once you walk on them. These stay flat on the bottom."
• "These are extremely cheap but durable flat insoles."
• "The cover material this is made for does last far longer than the typical cloth that dr scholls insoles are made from."
• "I am glad... so glad to have purchased my first pair of Odor-Eaters and YES! They work, they work aggressively to defeat my smelly GTX trail runners' stench."
• "I like these innersoles because they are thick enough to absorb the sweat, thus saving my feet from being wet and then getting cold."
• "These insoles keep your feet dry."
• "A quarter of the price of similar Dr. Scholls product- great for lining your winter slippers (or summer shoes)."

Cons:

• "They don’t stay put, they constantly slide forward and backwards, or even out of the rear of the shoe."
• "They worked for a few days and then started to fold up inside my boots."
• "Not worth the hassle and certainly not 'ultra durable' as they claim."
• "Ordered in sept. Completely shredded and falling apart unusable by New Years."
• "They were good for like a day then after a day they keep sliding around in my boots."
• "Almost immediately they started to crumble and fall apart."
• "They were fine while they lasted but the completely disintegrated in less than 3 months."

Sizing and Cutting

Pros:

• "I’ve used these for years. I also learned to get the best fit, this works best for me: I always trim the upper part and trim wider than what is stenciled on the soles."
• "These ones were easy to cut to my size according to the printed outlines."
• "Used this product in sneakers that I generally don't wear socks with. The insoles added extra comfort and were easy to cut trim to fit my size."

Cons:

• "I had never used Odor-Eaters before, so was inexperienced in cutting them out to shape my insoles."
• "Do NOT follow the lines they give you to cut."
• "Be careful when you cut them to your shoe size because following the guides can result in an insert way too small for the shoe."
• "Got the product to reduce odor in athletic shoes. The size cutting recommendations were a little off and the insole was smaller than the inside of the shoe."
• "Sole kept moving around my shoes and the cut guides were not clear/visible and not true to size."
• "These are narrow for a size 12 and I can feel the gaps on either side between the edge of the insert and each wall of the shoe."
• "I can't get my foot into the boot without them just bunching up and not laying flat."