Rimmel Exaggerate SmokeN Eyeliner Little Reviews Summary

Application & Texture

Pros:

• "Glides on smoothly and is nice and dark."
• "Goes on very smooth and stays long time."
• "Goes on smooth and easy, stays on all day...what's not to like about it?"
• "It goes on so smooth and easy. It never smudges or ends up where it shouldn’t."
• "This is hands down the best eye liner I have ever used. It stays all day and looks like I just applied it."
• "It’s really creamy and goes on very pigmented, I love it for tight lining because of how smooth it glides & also lasts all day."
• "This eyeliner goes on easily. It blends well and stays put all day until I take it off."

Cons:

• "I usually like this eyeliner, but the past couple of times I’ve gotten it it would just break off while using it."
• "It seems to run out quickly and you cannot see that it is to the end due to the container."
• "I put this on and it seemed to smudge well enough. Than after half an hour, it looked like I went swimming, all over the place, do not buy!"
• "Coverage isn't great and it takes too much time to make it look solid and sharp."
• "The pencil keeps breaking off every time I go to use it.. :( once your able to get it on you have to go back with a blending brush to even it out and get off the excess clumps."
• "It does not glide on, and crumbles when I try to slide it across my lid."
• "The first time I used it the tip crumbled off. I rolled it up and a big piece broke off."

Longevity & Waterproof

Pros:

• "I’ve used this eyeliner for years, and sadly it looks like Rimmel is discontinuing the product. I love it because it’s the only eyeliner that truly stays put."
• "Discovered this liner a few years back and it's all I've used since. Goes on smooth and easy, stays on all day...what's not to like about it?"
• "Stays on my waterline. Does not budge."
• "Very good eyeliner that lasts all day and looks great."
• "This is my favorite eye liner!! Everything in its description holds true.. Its definitely water proof and smudge proof."
• "This eyeliner stays put until I take it off."
• "I love this eyeliner! It doesn't run or smudge and stays on all day."

Cons:

• "Just like every 'waterproof' eyeliner I've used in my life it's just a scam."
• "It's not at all smudge proof though, with a few wipes is gone."
• "Absolutely not for the waterline or for tightlining. In 70F weather with no exertion, lasted approx 3 hours. Smudges."
• "I wont be buying this eyeliner again. It smudges, hard to apply ~ have to go back over several times, It's not exactly waterproof."
• "This is not at all waterproof, not even smudge proof! It smeared into my upper eye within 30 minutes of putting it on."
• "While it is waterproof it isn’t all that smudge proof."
• "Did not wear very well at all. Stayed on for a few hours but I need truly waterproof because I swim a lot."

Quality & Packaging

Pros:

• "I love the cushion tip to blend the liner."
• "Love how everything is built right into the product."
• "I love that the pencil comes with a built in Smudger, and a retractable tip."
• "I love the self sharpening option."
• "This liner is great. I have always had a problem with liner running down my eyes and looking crazy by the end of the day. This liner stays on and doesn't run."
• "I love this eyeliner. Very well priced, too!"
• "I love them because the colors are great they were well there is it to apply and the price is amazing I have every color."

Cons:

• "Good color and like the sponge blender an sharpener on the other side but did not last long like there was maybe not enough product inside."
• "This review is more based on the delivery status of the eyeliner, the eyeliner itself is a good quality product for the cost. However when i received my subscribe and save delivery the eyeliner package itself had been opened and it appeared that the liner was used."
• "Normally, I like Rimmel products. This eyeliner pencil was delivered with no lead inside of it!"
• "But this time I ordered it and when it came both ends of the package was open and the eye liner fell out..."
• "Beware they dnt offer returns…. Now I can see why. Both eyeliners came damaged."
• "So disappointed when I opened my purchase (set of 2) to find that one of the eyeliners was missing."
• "Ordered same item and received two different items, one ordered one not. Also the item I did not order was open. Very disappointed!!!"