Docolor Waterproof Eyeliner Super Liquid Reviews Summary

Longevity

Pros:

• "It also stays on pretty well, and definitely a great choice over expensive eyeliners from Sephora."
• "It goes on smoothly and lasts all day."
• "I’m still using the same docolor pen after months, and it truly is waterproof."
• "This eyeliner has seemed to stick in place longer and better than some rather expensive name-brands I’ve tried over the last few years."
• "Once this liner is dry, it stays on until you take it off."
• "Overall I am satisfied with the eyeliner because it stays as it should and 4x cheaper than Stila waterproof eyeliner."
• "It stays on all day!"

Cons:

• "This new formula smudges all over my eyelid within hours."
• "This is NOT waterproof. Within an hour of wearing this I looked like I had black eyes."
• "It went on smooth, but it was pretty much a hot mess after a little crying."
• "This didn't last the day for me."
• "Just bought another one and it is smearing off on my upper eyelids."
• "This did not last very long without smudging."
• "By 8 hrs this will look pretty Smokey."

Application

Pros:

• "Very simple to use (honestly doesn't get simpler than a felt tip pen)."
• "Easy to use."
• "Love the fine tip that’s stable."
• "The tip is wonderful for accuracy."
• "It goes on exacting, stays, doesn't run, and lasts all day."
• "The applicator is precise and the line it creates is very clean."
• "The felt tip made the application smooth and easy."

Cons:

• "I couldn't get my winged liner as precise...."
• "The pen takes some shaking initially to work well -- at first I only got a watery mess that feathered really quickly."
• "You need a very light hand to apply this eyeliner because it's so smooth, dark, rich, and full of color - if that makes sense."
• "The problem I'm having with it is it dries almost immediately so there's no room for error while applying it!"
• "It bled and never gave me a precise line like I wanted."
• "getting the cap off is challenging every time."
• "They changed the tip of the pen! It used to be a bunch of tiny little bristles bunched together... and they changed it!"

Waterproof Quality

Pros:

• "I love this eyeliner so much, It’s the only one I’ve found that is completely smudge proof!"
• "So I was pleasantly surprised by Docolor's waterproof eyeliner pen."
• "Easy application, super opaque, and pretty water proof."
• "It doesn’t smudge, it’s very potent, and stays ALL DAY."
• "It stays on all day and it goes on perfect!"
• "This eyeliner is great and all: water resistant, lasts all day."
• "It’s really waterproof."

Cons:

• "Unfortunately it is not waterproof. If your eyes tear up at all from laughter or simply being out in the wind, this eyeliner will crumble right off."
• "This is not waterproof. It slides and makes your eyelids stick when it does."
• "It's definitely not allergie proof."
• "This wasn’t as waterproof as I hoped."
• "The actual packaging does not say anything about waterproof (misleading advertisement on the website)."
• "Not at all waterproof."
• "This stuff doesn’t go on smoothly, takes forever to dry."

Packaging and Design

Pros:

• "I am ready to buy a dozen."
• "I’ve never had one that I am able to use underneath my lower lash line with such incredible staying power!"
• "This is a good waterproof liquid eyeliner gel."
• "I have sensitive skin and will have allergic reactions to various skin care and makeup products. I've been using this for two years and I haven't had any sensitivity issues."
• "Nice thin line, excellent packaging, as the top CLICKS on."
• "This liquid liner pen is great. I'm not a pro, but this is easy to apply and never smudges."
• "Absolutely the BEST liquid eye-liner I've EVER used."

Cons:

• "A major issue is the cap. It does not tightly cover the eyeliner and pops off, drying out the product."
• "For starters this product comes in a package that is easily tampered with."
• "When I received my new eyeliner, it came in a different package from what I usually receive, I did not think much of it and was just happy to have my makeup."
• "The first order I placed, never arrived and I was pretty disappointed."
• "Why does the price keep going up a whole dollar every time I need to buy a new eyeliner?!"
• "Also the BIGGEST CON: there is something weird about the cap of this eyeliner: every time I put it on, it bends the eyeliner brush."
• "But I found that it took a long time to dry causing a lot of smudges and difficulties when applying."